Audio by Ushy Fried

80:78 A chest whose lid isn't connected to it by hinges,1 it's forbidden to take (the lid) away from there, because that resembles dismantling a canopy.2 Similarly, it's forbidden to put the lid on it because that resembles making a canopy.3 When a board is placed over a barrel to serve as a table top, the open end of the barrel should be placed on the ground, for if one placed the board on the open end this would be like making a canopy.4

1) If it's attached with hinges, it's viewed as something made to be opened and closed constantly, like a door, and the prohibition against creating a canopy wouldn't apply. 2) We saw that both building - ''Boneh'' - and dismantling - ''Sotare'' - are ''Avot Melachot'' (prototype prohibited activities); both setting up a canopy and dismantling a canopy are prohibited as derivatives - ''toladot'' - of these ''Melachot''. 3) According to the Mishna Berurah (315:48), this prohibition only applies to objects with wide openings. There are opinions among the Rishonim (early authorities) that the prohibition against creating a canopy on Shabbat doesn't apply to covers of ''Kelim'' (movable vessels or furniture), however, the Mishna Berurah 315:49 rules that one should follow the more stringent opinion in this matter, which is held by the majority of authorities. 4) It's only considered creating a canopy if there is a hand-breadth (9-10cm) of space between the content of the barrel and the covering; if, however, the barrel is full, there is no prohibition against covering it (Shulchan Aruch 315:13).

תיבה שהכיסוי שלה אינו מחובר לה בצירים אסור ליטלו משם משום דהוי סותר אוהל וכן אסור לכסות בו משום דעושה אהל וכשנותנין טבלא על חבית להיות לשלחן צריכין להעמיד את החבית בצד הפתוח למטה שאם יתן את הדף על הצד הפתוח הרי הוא עושה אהל
80:79 The pipe from a chimney, if it comes out sideways, then blocking it is like adding a partition, and it's allowed to block it. However, if it comes out at the top it's forbidden to close it on Shabbat or festivals since that's like making a canopy. If there is permanently there an iron door that turns on hinges, it's permitted to close it, since it's permanently there it's like a door that turns on its' hinges.

פי העשן ארובה אם הוא מן הצד שהסתימה היא כמו תוספת מחיצה מותר לסותמו אבל אם הוא למעלה אסור לסותמו בשבת וביום טוב משום דעושה אהל ואם קבוע שם דלת של ברזל סובב על צירים מותר לסתום דכיון שהוא קבוע שם הוי ליה כדלת הסובבת על צירים

80:80 A cloth that's spread over the opening of a barrel to cover it: If the barrel is not completely full, rather there is between the liquids it contains and the cloth an empty space of a hand-breadth, the opening should not be covered entirely, because of (making) a canopy, rather one should leave a small portion of the opening uncovered.1

1) According to the Mishna Berurah (315:48), this prohibition only applies to objects with wide openings, whereas covering vessels with narrow openings would not be considered creating a canopy. There are opinions among the Rishonim (early authorities) that the prohibition against creating a canopy on Shabbat doesn't apply to covers of ''Kelim'' (movable vessels or furniture), however, the Mishna Berurah 315:49 rules that one should follow the more stringent opinion in this matter, which is held by the majority of authorities.

בגד ששוטחין על פי חבית לכסותה אם החבית אינה מלאה לגמרי אלא שיש בין המשקים שבתוכה להכיסוי חלל טפח אזי לא יכסה אותה על פני כולה משום אהל אלא יניח מקצת פיה מגולה

To subscribe click here. To unsubscribe click here
To learn about our program for Mishna Yomis click here